The VISA Black Card is a Joke

The only card you need

The only card you need

 

First, how pathetic is it that VISA can’t even come up with an original idea?

If you’re not familiar, American Express created its mythic Centurion card, known to the proletariat as the “black card”, in 1999. Beyond gold, beyond platinum, beyond californium or whatever the most expensive element in the periodic table now is, the Centurion card was available to such an exclusive subset of American Express cardholders that the company barely acknowledged its existence, let alone advertised it. If you qualified, they’d let you know. They’d also charge you $7500 for the privilege, plus a $2500 annual fee. Even today, in a world where the internet has made secrets scarcer and harder to keep, the card retains as discreet a profile as possible. The card’s website, Centurion.com, is not what you’d call ostentatious.

Even though credit cards have evolved and been democratized, turning from status symbols into mere necessities, the American Express brand still manages to retain some kind of cachet. Looking to challenge that cachet, in 2008 VISA introduced its Centurion competitor – the unoriginally monikered Black Card®. Seriously, that’s what they called it. Imagine Honda calling its new economy car the Bug, or the Cincinnati Bengals calling their end zone bleacher section the Dawg Pound, and you’d have an idea how this dances around the edge of copyright infringement without stepping over.

How about some other, more legitimate reasons why the Black Card (capitalized) is absurd? For one thing, it’s Made of Stainless Steel℠. And yes, they really did go to the trouble of attaching a service mark to that phrase. Exactly how is that a plus? So you can impress the clerk with an authoritative clink while slapping your card down on the marble desk at the Mandarin Oriental? Or is it to garner even more attention from TSA agents while shuffling through the shoeless indignity that is modern American air travel? Either way, that sounds like the opposite of the discretion that most truly wealthy people prefer.

You know what our PayPal accounts are made out of? Nothing. Literally, nothing. Neither are our bank’s wire transfers and direct deposits. If only they were made from (excuse us, “forged”–sounds classier) stainless steel, we’d be enjoying a money-having experience far superior to that endured by the huddled middle class.

Here’s what $495 gets you, assuming VISA selects you to buy your way into Black Card membership:

  • A magazine. Not just any magazine, but “the ultimate luxury guide [that] showcases the finest in travel, fashion, transportation, technology, interior design and art.” It’s for members only, just like the jackets. Again, we have the internet now. If information exists in printed or printable form, it’s available to everyone. Even entry-level cardholders. Besides, magazines, at least at our house, are literally* garbage. (If you want the latest issue of American Rifleman or Vegas Living, you’re welcome to wade through our trash cans.) These days, a magazine is something you buy at an airport newsstand because you want something to read, your Kindle is low on juice, and you can’t be bothered to fish its power cord out of your luggage and find a place to sit that’s near a power outlet. Speaking of airports,

 

  • Visits at “over 350 lounges in 200 cities worldwide.” Wow, that’s more than 1.75 lounges per city. We’re not here to denigrate airport lounges in principle, as sitting with the masses can sometimes be its own punishment. But if you’re spending so much time waiting for connecting flights that this sounds like an agreeable perk to you, then you’re rich enough that you can find a secretary who can reduce your layovers while she books your flights.

 

  • A 24-hour concierge, who can give you “local shopping information” and details on “highlights/sights/exhibitions/shows.” One more time, the internet. If you can afford $495 for a Black Card, you can afford $495 for an iPhone that will tell you what the time in Incheon, South Korea is without having to call anyone. Besides, if you’re that desperate to live the life of the upwardly-immobile-because-you’re-already-at-the-top, shouldn’t you already have a personal assistant at your beck and call? One who will help you with even more intimate problems than a VISA employee with a headset can? “Hi, Janie? It’s Mr. Smith. What’s the name of that guy we called to bury that hooker last time? No, I don’t need another hooker buried. But he also said he could secure some krokodil, and I was feeling more indulgent than usual tonight. I tried the Black Card concierge and she said she was legally forbidden from helping me with this. Bitch. What am I paying her for?”

And, as if the concierge at a call center in Fort Wayne is going to be able to find you a dog groomer in Madrid any better than you can do it yourself.

  • Global Acceptance. For your convenience, your Black Card is accepted in over 170 countries worldwide with no foreign transaction fees.”

(Just to clarify, that’s for your convenience, and not for your vexation.) Still though, what a perk! It’s not as if every other card with a VISA logo on it isn’t accepted in all those countries.

There’s also a plethora of arcane services that you’re never going to need and certainly wouldn’t be able to justify the $495 purchase of. Like late checkout, which can usually be had by asking the hotel employee nicely. Or “auto rental collision damage waiver,” which you already have if you have car insurance. Or reimbursement for “essential items in the event of baggage delay.” A $3000 laptop doesn’t count as an essential item, either. You get $100 of reimbursement a day up to a total of $300. That’s a lot of dental floss.

Adorably, VISA compares its own shiny apple to a decomposing American Express orange and doesn’t expect people to notice the unfair comparison:

 

Black Card

 

If the folks at VISA didn’t hate us before–after all, they’ve been losing money on us since we first signed up and started our uninterrupted pattern of paying our balances in full every month, as responsible people do–they probably do now. Glad to be of help.

 

*That’s 2 uses of “literally” in this post, both of them accurate and neither of them superfluous.

October’s (F)RotM, Now in Acronym Form

lowest-paying-job-fast-food

 

Control Your Cash entered into a new professional venture a few weeks ago, with an agreeable fellow who made one modest condition: that we no longer employ the word “retard” on the site. (He’ll hopefully excuse that instance of it, given that it wasn’t gratuitous but rather vital to the plot. Like Thora Birch’s nudity in American Beauty.) We could have stood our ground, but it was a battle hardly worth fighting. And it reminded us of a quote that we can’t remember the source of, but want to use on the jacket of our next book:

 

The world is full of fast food cooks who never took flak from anybody. 

 

So yeah, our monthly feature is now the (F)RotM. The F is for financial, the o is for of, and you can search through our archives to figure out the rest. For some reason we let the feature go last month, not properly honoring anyone as our (F)RotM, so we looked doubly hard to find someone fitting this time. And succeeded.

Debt bloggers are the freaking Hydra. You have to not only cut off the head, but cauterize the stump to stop two more from growing in its place. Like our latest (F)RotM laureate, No Debt Brunette. Misogyny may be more of a pastime for us here than it is an overarching worldview, but it’s hard to take some of the ladies seriously when they willingly reduce themselves to something as trivial and inconsequential as a hair color. (There’s also a Budget Blonde, and probably a Recession-Proof Redhead*, too.) Anyhow, here’s what makes No Debt Brunette such an original:

I have almost $25,000 worth of debt and have decided to regain control of my life.

See if you can distinguish her from this previous winner:

My name is Tricia and my husband and I got into a little bit of debt in our 20s. Okay…it’s more than a little bit of debt. When we finally decided to shape up our financial life in February of 2006, our credit card debt was over $37,000.

Or this one:

I had debt that I couldn’t pay on, student loans that I hadn’t paid on in years, no job, I lived at home with my mother & my two young boys and my car had just gone its last mile. I sat in my room and cried for a good two hours.

(The blogger cried. Do you even need to guess the sex?) Then there’s this one:

I was over $45,000+ in student loan debt as I was entering the “real world”. […] Along with my student loans, I also have about $13,000+ in credit card debt.

Or this one:

I found myself with $50,000 worth of credit card debt, all of which I created myself.

There are hundreds more. Literally hundreds. The only thing remarkable about them, as a collective, is their stunning uniformity. As individuals, they’re each as unique as the capsules in this bottle of Kirkland® brand fish oil. And about as palatable.

can-i-give-my-baby-fish-oil

Back to No Debt Brunette, who not only has a negative balance, but a goal!

I am on a year long Spending Freeze where I only pay necessities. Instead of spending money on fun things like new clothes and sodas, I am putting it towards my bills.

“Spending Freeze” is capitalized, meaning that she’s attaching some importance to it. Also, we’ve uncovered a new level of pathos where a soda counts as a “fun thing” to spend money on. (Last we checked, Walmart cola runs about 20¢ a can, excluding deposit.) She wrote that promise earlier this year, March or so. You already know what her progress has been like over the last 7 months, but let’s examine the failures and corresponding excuses here. Starting with last Wednesday:

I’m already 23 days into my Spending Freeze: Take Two!

Take Two? Back up a minute. What happened?

When I started this adventure in February of last year, my beginning debt balance was $24,996.98.

So, subtract all the money I payed toward that total, add all the charges I made during my move, add a car loan and I now have a debt total of $37,472.79.

When you’re 25 large in the hole, well, why wouldn’t you take out a car loan? Ally Financial has quarterly quotas to meet. No Debt Brunette is now tantalizingly close to half again as much debt as she had when she started this charade. It’s actually 49.9%, to one decimal place. How do you describe someone who’s detailed enough to ratiocinate her debt to the nearest penny, twice, yet who commits to lowering her debt and then raises it by half? Wait, let’s hear her rationalization. This is great:

I know I know, the balance increased dramatically instead of decreasing. I could have only incorporated the amount of student loan debt that I have left but I want to be real and focus on becoming COMPLETELY debt free, including paying for my car.

Is that latter sentence even English? We’ve said before that the only way to become debt-free, assuming you were stupid enough to have incurred debt in the first place, is to live like a panhandler until your net worth is finally back up to zero. No new clothes, no new entertainment, no new nothing (except groceries) until you’re done. Why? Because intense pain concentrated into as short a time as possible beats protracted dull pain every time. The Band-Aid principle, if you will. Eventually you figure you can live with the dull pain, as it chips away at your self-worth, both metaphorical and financial, one day at a time. But no worries, because this time it’s going to be different. No Debt Brunette (what a grossly misleading moniker) knows all the platitudes, too. Listen to her delude herself:

I feel like a seasoned veteran now and know what needs to be done. I am going to spend this next week meal planning, taking photos of stuff I can sell online, and preparing myself mentally for this new journey. Starting a Spending Freeze right around the holidays is going to be tough but I’m excited to do it.

As a rule, taking time to “prepar[e] [one]self mentally” is not a step undertaken by achievers. Also, what holidays occur around October 1? Diwali?

It gets better. It always gets better. Before Spending Freeze 2.0 began in earnest, she had to get some expenditures out of the way. Expenditures that might have made sense if she were living in 1960:

I decided to send thank you cards to people in my life who have recently done something kind for me. If the person is in my everyday life then I will hand deliver the card (saving postage) but if not, I’m okay with spending 47 cents on them. I have about 8 stamps left but my Spending Fast is serious business. So, I am going to buy a $10 pack of stamps to hold me over till I can ask for more for Christmas.

  1. You’re going to buy a $10 pack of stamps to “hold you over’? This is all over the WGAS channel.
  2. We have this thing called email now. It’s free.

But that’s so impersonal.

And you’re $37,473 in debt! God, do we have to spell out everything? By the way, we’ll be expecting a card shortly for being the only people with sufficient reserves of tough love to tell you frankly what an absolute moron you’re being.

There’s another minor expense that she declares she has to take care of before she decides to again think about lowering her (now greatly heightened) debt, too:

I committed to a few things in October. My BFF Lauren is getting married next weekend and I have booked a hotel already. I committed to visiting my best man friend in VA in a few weeks and I’m traveling to DC for a high-school-lady-friend-reunion.

[W]hile it would save a little money if I didn’t go, I’ve learned that people are more important than money.

Then WTF is the point of your website? Why not just say “I’m drowning in debt, it’s getting worse, but I like spending money and seeing my friends so there’s no point worrying about it”, The End? We know you’re not serious about getting out of debt, that much is obvious, but could you at least pretend to care for the sake of this website that you’ve put so much wasted effort into?

The wedding was last week, or at least her recap of it was.

I had to constantly stay aware of my purchases. I had allotted $300 for this trip.

If people really are more important than money, why didn’t the bride say, “Look, you’re broke. I know you’re broke, because you’ve dedicated a blog to how poor you are. Maybe you should sit this one out.” Oh, that’s right, women are insane. The Brunette also had to board her dog for a few days at $40 a night. Dogs are more important than money, too.

(No, we’re not being facetious. Control Your Cash’s charity of choice remains Best Friends Animal Society, mostly because its beneficiaries aren’t responsible for making any stupid decisions.)

It’s not the immaturity nor the crying jags that get us in the (F)RotM series, it’s these people’s endless refusal to look in the mirror and comment honestly on what they see. If you want to spend money injudiciously, just freaking do it and stop pretending to care about ever getting out of debt. More to the point, stop thinking that your repeated and unrepentant failure is of interest to anyone.

Buy assets, sell liabilities, build wealth. That sequence never, ever fails.
Get in debt, get further in debt, rationalize your awful choices, spend money in contradiction of your alleged goals, fall even further behind, die broke. That one never fails either. Your choice.

*No, but there is a Red-Debted Stepchild. Thanks to a frequent Carnival of Wealth contributor for the last-minute research.